The Heart in Conflict

Gabriel Powell | August 7, 2018

How long has it been since your last conflict?

Many of us could count the hours—maybe even minutes. We are sandpaper people in a sandpaper world. Friction is a fact of life.

A needy child interrupts your morning devotions. A co-worker unjustly blames you for a failed project. The church critic wants to speak with you about yesterday’s sermon. Your spouse makes plans without consulting the calendar. There are innumerable scenarios in life and ministry where conflict erupts.

Eliphaz did not speak rightly about God as Job did, but he was right about man when he said, “Man is born for trouble as sparks fly upward” (Job 5:7).  This saying is trustworthy: whenever two sinners interact, there is a high likelihood of sparks.

In order to handle conflict in a way that glorifies God and promotes reconciliation with others, we must first understand the heart of the issue.

The Source of All Things: A Biblical View of the Heart

Conflict is not primarily the result of personality differences, miscommunication, or unfortunate circumstances. Those may play a role in escalating or complicating a conflict, but they are not the true source. The true source of conflict is the same as the source of all things in life—the heart.

God has revealed the nature of humanity in Scripture. That is a more significant reality than most people realize. The corollary reality is that the nature of humanity—who we really are—cannot be discovered through secular anthropology, philosophy, medicine, or psychology. In other words, it is impossible for mankind to discover his own nature by natural means. God has given us truth in Scripture that cannot be known by any other means.

What has God revealed? All of life—thoughts, desires, intentions, words, actions—rises out of the heart (Prov 4:23). The heart has intentions and purposes (Gen 6:5; Heb 4:12), the heart makes plans (Prov 20:5), offers thanksgiving (Ps 111:1), speaks (Luke 6:46), hates (Lev 19:17), forgives (Matt 18:35), and loves God and others (Matt 22:34-40). All of life—sin and righteousness—flows out from the heart (Prov 15:28; Mark 7:20-23).

In this context, the heart is not the blood-pumping organ. The heart is the immaterial part of a man or woman synonymous with their spirit or soul (Prov 2:10; 17:22). It is the inner man (Rom 7:22; 2 Cor 4:16) which is either being renewed by the Spirit or corrupted by sin (Eph 4:22-23). The heart is the deepest part of man—it is the control center of life. A person is no more or less than the nature of their heart (Prov 23:7).

This is why God is concerned first and foremost with the heart (Jer 17:9-10), and why a new heart is a critical component of the New Covenant (Eze 36:26). When God looks for worshippers, He looks for those who worship from the heart, because the heart alone manifests one’s true devotion (Isa 29:13; John 4:23).

The Primary Occupation of the Heart

As the control center of life, the heart is busy doing a lot of things. But there is one occupation that rises above the rest by design—the heart worships.

Worship is what happens when we ascribe to a person or object the ability control the world, meet needs, provide protection, bring happiness, and satisfy desires. This is why the world is full of function-specific gods and idols—gods of fertility, war, love, weather, and so on. Humans worship and serve the particular god they truly believe can meet their particular need.

No wonder the first and second commandments are at the top of the list (Exodus 20:1-6). We are to have no other gods other than the Lord our God, and we are not to look to any created thing as representative of God. We are not to worship or serve anything other than God because there is no other god like our God or who can do what God alone can do. Indeed, all other gods are nothing and can do nothing (Deut 4:28; Ps 115:4-8).

As the One who searches men’s hearts, the Lord knows when our worship is genuine or false—when it is from the heart or merely on the lips (Isa 29:13).  No matter what we profess, we worship false gods when our heart turns away from the Lord (Deut 11:16). Those who serve false gods and worship them refuse to listen to truth because they are committed to following their own heart (Jer 13:10). In fact, idols are made in the heart long before the hand carves the wood (Eze 14:4).

Modern western culture is not unlike Athens where Paul was provoked by the multitude of idols (Acts 17). What the world—and, unfortunately, many Christians—calls felt needs are really desires of the heart. There are many legitimate needs and desires—food, shelter, protection, rest, and pleasure—which in their proper context and measure can be satisfied by God-honoring means. But whether legitimate or illegitimate, desires that are disordered or unmeasured lead to idolatry.

Conflicting Desires

This side of the garden of Eden, the natural propensity of the human heart is to seek the fulfillment of its desires by any means necessary. Today’s world economy is no less dependent on idols than was Ephesus (Acts 19:24-26). The temple prostitutes of old have been replaced by the endless stream of technology, activities, relationships, and lifestyles. They tempt you to think that your life will be exponentially improved by fractional changes to your possessions or circumstances.

How does any of this relate to conflict? James writes, “What is the source of quarrels and conflicts among you? Is not the source your pleasures that wage war in your members? You lust and do not have; so you commit murder. You are envious and cannot obtain; so you fight and quarrel.” (4:1-2, emphasis added).

The answer to James’ simple and direct question—what causes conflict?—is equally simple and direct. We have conflict because our desires conflict with God’s and others’. When a driver pulls in front of you, you get angry because you wanted to be in front of them. When your spouse arrives late or your child acts out at the grocery store, you get angry because their actions conflict with your desires and expectations.

Each and every conflict you have within yourself and with others rises out of a conflict of desires—desires which might even be inherently good, but which are disordered or unmeasured. These desires rule over you as manifested by how they control your thoughts, words, and actions. They have truly become—even if only temporarily—idols of the heart.

Three ways to evaluate your desires

How do you know if your desires are disordered or unmeasured? There are a number of ways one could evaluate desires, but here are three simple questions:

Am I wanting something that violates God’s revealed will?

Scripture contains truths and principles that enable us to determine whether God has commanded, forbidden, or allowed what we desire. If our desires conflict with God’s desires, they are disordered.

Am I willing to sin in order to obtain my desires?

We can want a good thing, but sin in our pursuit of it. If we do, our desire has become unmeasured. We want it too much—wanting it more than we want to honor the Lord.

Am I willing to sin when I don’t obtain my desires?

This is perhaps the most common manifestation of disordered and unmeasured desires for Christians. In many situations our desires are good, and we don’t sin to obtain them, but we sin when we can’t have them. We want our children to obey, but they don’t, so we get angry. We want our spouse to love us in certain ways, but they don’t so we make them feel our displeasure. We want our church to follow our leadership, but they don’t so we become bitter toward them. We desire a spouse or a certain career or educational opportunity, but God’s providence has not brought it to pass, so we become bitter toward the Lord.

When we want what God doesn’t want, or we sin to obtain what we want, or we sin when we can’t have what we want, we manifest that our heart has promoted those desires to rule over us. We have set up a god above the Lord.

The Only Remedy

Dr. Ernie Baker often says, “If false worship is the problem, true worship is the solution.”

If the true source of our conflicts with each other are disordered and unmeasured desires within us—sin—then we have failed to keep the first and greatest commandment to love God with all our heart, soul, mind, and strength (Mark 12:30).

Some conflicts may represent a momentary lapse of judgment. Others may reveal long-standing and deep-seated desires that have captured the heart. Whatever the case, as you examine your heart and consider the desires at work in your conflict, the starting point in pursuing reconciliation is confessing your disordered or unmeasured desires to the Lord, seeking His forgiveness, and putting your desires in their rightful place—under the lordship of Christ.

Making peace with the person on the other end of the conflict will have temporal benefits, but the soul will not be settled until we make peace with God by confessing and repenting of our sinful desires and adopting His desires for our situation and life. What’s more, it is remarkable how putting our desires in their place and adopting Christ’s desires for our situation often—not always—clears the path toward reconciliation with others.

Conclusion

Conflict is inevitable. Until our desires are perfectly aligned to Christ’s in glory, we cannot escape the friction that often happens when two sinners rub shoulders. But if you find that you are involved in frequent and intense conflict, perhaps it is time to examine your heart, asking the Lord to reveal your own hidden faults and desires (Ps 139:23-24).

This is just the start—we haven’t begun to discuss what steps need to be taken with the other person. For that and more in-depth consideration of the principles presented here, see the recommended resources below.

Settling for superficial peace and the ceasing of hostilities is tempting. But the goal of the believer is to glorify God by being conformed to the image of Christ. That can only happen when we deal with the heart first and foremost.


Recommended Resources

The Freedom and Power of Forgiveness by John MacArthur
Help! I’m in Conflict by Ernie Baker
The Peacemaker by Ken Sande
Pursuing Peace by Robert Jones

The substance and ideas in this post are largely taken from a seminar I taught using material produced by Dr. John Street. Most of what I’ve learned in this arena has come from Dr. Street and Dr. Ernie Baker. I am grateful for their faithful teaching and influence in my life.


Gabriel Powell avatar
Gabriel Powell earned his M.Div. from TMS in 2011. He currently oversees the internet ministry of Grace to You.

Join Our Mailing List

Here's what you can expect from us:

Doctrine, discourse, & doxology delivered to your inbox.

Articles from trusted TMS faculty and friends.

A free eBook for your enjoyment.

No spam.

Related Posts

Helping People Reconcile image

Helping People Reconcile

Eric Dodson | September 30, 2015

Philemon. It’s one of the shortest books in the Bible, a brief epistle that makes up what it lacks in word count with a dynamic message on forgiveness, fellowship, and unity in the church. Since it was first penned by the apostle Paul, this powerful little letter has continued to impact the lives of individual believers […]

When Others Mistreat You image

When Others Mistreat You

Nathan Busenitz | May 28, 2015

When other people treat us badly, or backstab us, or wrongly speak ill of us, how are we to respond? Jeremiah Burroughs, in The Rare Jewel of Contentment, answers that question by reminding us that, even when others mistreat us, it is no excuse for growing anxious, angry, or discontent. He says this: * * * […]

Counseling the Fainthearted image

Counseling the Fainthearted

John Street | May 5, 2015

A look at the greatness of our Savior God provides a necessary perspective for biblical help for fainthearted Christians (cf. Isaiah 9:6; 11:1; 28:29; 40:10–11). If you are going to be a pastor who practices caring, loving counsel, you need to be like your Savior. You are not going to just preach from the pulpit. […]